Quikly
← Blog

New customer acquisition: How to convert existing email subscribers

Lindsay Keener · January 14, 2022

person-looking-at-computer-with-credit-card-in-hand

Two things are for certain: gaining the attention of consumers and convincing them to join your email list can have their difficulties. You’ve done both. Now, you’ve got your sights set on getting those email subscribers to become customers

New customer acquisition plays a major role in the growth of your brand. The good news is that email subscribers recognize your brand’s value and appreciate it enough to keep up with your marketing content — the only thing left to do is show them how that value can grow once they become a customer.

We spoke with Ben Miller, founder of Focus on Digital, a web design and digital marketing agency based in the United Kingdom, to discuss how this sort of email conversion can occur. Miller says you must create strong relationships with your subscribers, understand consumer buyer behavior and leverage marketing psychology to help influence subscribers to become customers.

What does it take to convert a new email subscriber into a new customer?

Embarking on the mission of acquiring new customers requires you to go back to the basics. Here’s one fundamental rule worth considering: All conversions are achieved through strong customer relationships and brand value. 

“To convert a new email subscriber into a new customer, the company must develop a relationship with that person over time through a series of interactions,” said Miller. “A key component to any marketing campaign is to have a robust and interactive product site so as customers navigate the site, they are served up with relevant content, deals and incentives for them to purchase from the company.”

When you’re providing your subscribers with an easy-to-understand platform complete with attractive offers and rewards, don’t forget to focus on their needs. 

“A new email subscriber is converted into a new customer through the customer’s desire to fulfill their wants and needs. A large amount of research has been done to analyze how consumers make decisions on what they want to buy, with these findings proving that consumers take into account their past experiences with the company, what others have told them about the company and whether or not the company seems trustworthy,” said Miller.

How can marketers create excitement to encourage conversions?

Part of your ability to motivate subscribers to become customers is your ability to invoke anticipation around your brand. Consumer anticipation is no small concept, and it certainly shouldn’t be overlooked, especially when there are so many brands out there who would love the chance to have your subscribers as customers. Fortunately, you can use marketing psychology tactics to keep your subscribers engaged and focused on you. 

Creating excitement starts in-house. How can your subscribers feel excited about your brand if you don’t show them what there is to be interested in? Miller says that’s the first step.

“Marketers need to show their brand as being exciting and fun, as well as different from other brands. This can be done by emphasizing the uniqueness of the product or service being offered, and by displaying a sense of pride in having this product or service,” said Miller.

Ever heard a story that made you excited to learn more about a brand? Miller says powerful storytelling can also encourage your subscribers to make consistent purchases. 

“Marketers can create anticipation or excitement around their brand enough to encourage subscription by incorporating storytelling, which is a technique that helps consumers understand the company story and produces trust. This technique is discussed in depth in Joseph Campbell’s (2009) book, “The Power of Myth (The First Storytellers).” The author suggests that marketers should store information such as store history and company values within stories,” said Miller.

Creating the perfect transition from subscriber to customer is a top priority for many marketers and we can understand why. Having a strong understanding of your target audience and their minds can help you achieve your goal. 

(Learn more about how to turn email subscribers into customers here.)

Keep reading

Email MarketingUrgency Marketingshopify conversionscatching subject lines for emailsemail subject lines

10 Catching Subject Lines for Emails That Drive Urgency & ROI in 2026

In e-commerce, the battle for customer attention is won or lost in the inbox. With an industry average cart abandonment rate nearing 70% and a typical conversion rate hovering around 2.5%, top-performing Shopify stores consistently outperform these benchmarks, not by chance, but by design. The secret lies in mastering the science of urgency and consumer psychology, starting with the most critical element: the email subject line. A subject line's purpose extends far beyond simply securing an open; it must initiate a psychological journey that leads directly to a purchase and impacts revenue.

Feb 10, 2026

Email MarketingCustomer Retentionecommerce strategyorder confirmation mail

Master the Order Confirmation Mail to Boost ROI and Loyalty

The moment a customer clicks "buy," their entire mindset shifts. Behavioral economics tells us this is a peak moment of emotional investment and anticipation, making your customer incredibly receptive to your next move. This is why the order confirmation mail isn't just an automated receipt; it's your most powerful marketing asset, landing in their inbox at the exact moment of maximum engagement.

Feb 9, 2026

Email MarketingConversion Rate OptimizationUrgency Marketingshopify marketinge-commerce marketing strategies

12 High-Impact E-commerce Marketing Strategies to Boost Revenue in 2026

In today's competitive landscape, generic e-commerce marketing strategies no longer deliver the necessary ROI. While the average e-commerce conversion rate hovers around a mere 2.5% and cart abandonment plagues nearly 70% of checkouts, top-performing brands aren't just spending more; they're operating smarter. They leverage the science of consumer psychology to build sophisticated, automated marketing engines that drive predictable revenue growth while protecting profit margins.

Jan 30, 2026

Don't take our word for it.
See it on your store.

Enter your URL to get a free urgency campaign tailored to your store and goals.